FC Barcelona apparently tried to sign Brazilian midfielder Oscar from China on a free six-month loan. The catch? The deal hinged on defender Samuel Umtiti leaving first.
Oscar himself confirmed the near-move, revealing that Barcelona had approached him about a short-term deal that would have cost the club essentially nothing in transfer fees.
The economics of desperation
Oscar had been playing in the Chinese Super League with Shanghai SIPG since 2017, having left Chelsea for a reported massive payday in Asia. The Brazilian midfielder, who was 31 at the time of the Barcelona approach, had expressed interest in returning to European football. Barcelona saw an opportunity: an experienced midfielder with Premier League and Champions League pedigree, available for essentially zero upfront cost.
The problem was Barcelona’s wage bill. Even a free transfer requires paying the player’s salary, and Barcelona’s books were so constrained that they needed Umtiti, the French center-back whose massive contract had become an albatross around the club’s neck, to depart first. They literally couldn’t afford to add even a free player without subtracting someone else’s wages first.
Umtiti’s situation was its own saga. Once a World Cup-winning defender, chronic knee injuries had reduced his playing time to near zero. Yet he remained on a contract that paid him handsomely, and he showed little interest in voluntarily taking a pay cut or leaving. Barcelona was stuck with a player they couldn’t use and couldn’t afford, blocking moves for players they actually wanted.
Short-term thinking in a long-term sport
The January transfer window represented Barcelona’s opportunity to bring in reinforcements for a La Liga campaign that had been challenging. Oscar, with his experience at Chelsea and the Brazilian national team, would have provided midfield depth without the financial commitment of a multi-year deal.
The Umtiti dependency created a domino effect: one player’s refusal to leave directly prevented another player’s arrival.
Disclosure: This article was edited by Editorial Team. For more information on how we create and review content, see our Editorial Policy.
